Fine-Tuning Control Charts: Alternatives to X-bar R and X-bar S Charts


X-bar R, X-bar S and Individual charts are often the focus of control chart discussions. In fact, they are frequently presented as the only options for statistical process control charting. There are actually other alternatives. This discussion will look at the benefits of EWMA, exponentially weighted moving average, and moving average or uniformly weighted moving average, UWMA, charts. This article will discuss the data requirements and the advantages of the Moving Average EWMA and UWMA charts.

X-Bar and Individual charts are valuable for detecting relatively large shifts in the process mean. The definition of additional rules, for example the Western Electric rules, are attempts to increase the sensitivity of these charts. EWMA and Moving Average charts can detect relatively small shifts in the process mean faster than X-bar charts with the same sample size.

Moving Average and EWMA charts vary in the calculation of the plotted average values. A Moving Average or UWMA chart weights the values uniformly over time. An EWMA chart allows the user to determine the amount of weight given to prior data. The EWMA statistic gives progressively less weight to data that are further removed in time. This weighting factor is commonly represented by the symbol lambda. Lambda varies from 0 to 1. The smaller values of lambda give greater influence to historical data. For example, lambda = .4 means that 60% of the weight will be given to past information and 40% to current information. A lambda = 1 is equivalent to an X-bar chart.

One advantage of Moving Average charts is the lack of sensitivity to normality assumptions. If the dataset subgroup size = 1, an appropriate alternative is the Individual X chart. For this chart, it is necessary to estimate the distribution of the process in order to define the control limits. In contrast, the data points on an EWMA or Moving Average chart are averaged values. The estimate of the process distribution becomes less important since the data points are averages or moving averages. The Central Limit Theorem can be invoked to describe the distribution of the averages as normally distributed.

Another advantage of Moving Average charts is that they smooth the affects of known, uncontrollable noise in data. This is important where fluctuations exist, yet the fluctuations are not completely indicative of process instability.

Before opting to construct Moving Range charts, it is necessary to inspect the Range chart for the data. If any of the Range chart values are out of control, it is necessary to remove them from the data set.

The following Range chart illustrates at least one data point that must be removed.

grchart Core_width by 5 /tip_stats = data range x

Removing the data point and reviewing the chart shows that the ranges are now acceptable.

omit all (18) grchart Core_width by 5 /tip_stats = data range x

The following charts compare the differences in the X-Bar chart, the EWMA and Moving Average charts using this data.

gxchart Core_width by 5/tip_stats = data mean x

gmvavg Core_width by 5/ewma=.1 /approximate=5 /tip_stats = data mean x

gmvavg Core_width by 5 /tip_stats = data mean x

If you would like additional information, please send email to statit.support@acs-inc.com.